Home > Cookie Trays > Cookie Trays - In Store Pick UP
Sort By:
Page of 2
Winter Cookie Tray - Small - Pick Up
Winter Cookie Tray - Small - Pick Up
Our Price: $36.50

This tray includes an assortment of three and a half dozen cookies. Our number one selling cookie is our Cut Out Cookie, which beautifully accentuates this seasonal cookie tray.
Hearts Cookie Tray - Small - Pick up
Hearts Cookie Tray - Small - Pick up
Our Price: $36.50

We use our famous heart shaped cut out sugar cookies throughout the year for many special occasions. Not only are these trays great for a BRIDAL SHOWER or WEDDING RECEPTION , but we use hearts for SYMPATHY trays as well. You can let us know whatever color of base icing and drop flower on the hearts you choose so you can coordinate with the bride's wedding colors just by letting us know in the message box, or calling us.
This tray has 3 1/2 dozen of our most popular cookies.
Valentine Cookie Tray - Small - Pick up
Valentine Cookie Tray - Small - Pick up
Our Price: $36.50

3 1/2 dozen of delicious cookies including our heart shaped cut out cookies.  This tray has 11 different kinds of our most popular cookies.
Winter Cookie Tray - Medium - Pick Up
Winter Cookie Tray - Medium - Pick Up
Our Price: $47.00

This tray includes an assortment of five dozen cookies. Our number one selling cookie is our Cut Out Cookie, which beautifully accentuates this seasonal cookie tray.
Hearts Cookie Tray - med - pick up
Hearts Cookie Tray - med - pick up
Our Price: $47.00

We use our famous heart shaped cut out sugar cookies throughout the year for many special occasions. Not only are these trays great for a BRIDAL SHOWER or WEDDING RECEPTION, but we use hearts for SYMPATHY trays as well. You can let us know whatever color of base icing and drop flower on the hearts you choose so you can coordinate with the bride's wedding colors just by letting us know in the message box, or calling us.
We're here to serve you. This tray has 5 dozen of our most popular cookies.
Valentine Cookie Tray - Medium - Pick Up
Valentine Cookie Tray - Medium - Pick Up
Our Price: $47.00

5 dozen of our most popular cookies are tastefully arranged on our medium Valentine cookie tray.
Large Winter Cookie Tray (8 dozen) - Pick Up
Large Winter Cookie Tray (8 dozen) - Pick Up
Our Price: $70.00

This tray includes an assortment of eight dozen cookies (16 different kinds of cookies). Our number one selling cookie is our Cut Out Cookie, which beautifully accentuates this seasonal cookie tray.
Hearts Cookie Tray - Large - pick up
Hearts Cookie Tray - Large - pick up
Our Price: $70.00

This tray includes 8 dozen of 16 different types of cookies. We use hearts for many special occasions including WEDDINGS, BRIDAL SHOWERS, and SYMPATHY trays.
You can choose your own color of base icing and flower to coordinate with your wedding - just let us know.
Large Valentine Cookie Tray - Pick Up
Large Valentine Cookie Tray - Pick Up
Our Price: $70.00

Our Large Valentine cookie tray has 8 dozen of our most popular cookies (16 different kinds).
Extra Large Winter Cookie Tray (12 dozen) - Pick Up
Extra Large Winter Cookie Tray (12 dozen) - Pick Up
Our Price: $106.00

This tray includes an assortment of 12 dozen cookies (17 different kinds of cookies). Our number one selling cookie is our Cut Out Cookie, which beautifully accentuates this seasonal cookie tray.