Home > Pies > In Store Pick Up Only
Sort By:
Page of 2
Apple Dumpling - Pick up
Apple Dumpling - Pick up
Our Price: $4.95

We used to sell these apple dumplings as a fall only pastry but they were so popular people were asking for them all year.
We start with Granny Smith apple cut up with a cinnamon sugar. They are baked in a cinnamon sauce and we include a small container of the sauce for you to heat up with your dumpling.
Pumpkin Pie - Pick up (Seasonal)
Pumpkin Pie - Pick up (Seasonal)
Our Price: $11.00

Fresh baked pumpkin pie is loaded with spices of the season.
Sold from October - December
French Apple Pie - Pick Up
French Apple Pie - Pick Up
Our Price: $14.00

This hand made pie features lots of sliced apples, with a brown sugar crumb topping.
Country Apple Pie - Pick Up
Country Apple Pie - Pick Up
Our Price: $14.00

For pick up only.  Traditional apple pie like grandma used to make.  It's loaded with  apples and topped with a handmade crust.
Key Lime Pie (Seasonal) - Pick Up
Key Lime Pie (Seasonal) - Pick Up
Our Price: $14.00

It's the hit of the summer!! Excluding Thanksgiving time, we've sold more of this pie during the summer than any other pie.
We use a graham cracker crust and bake the tangy Key Lime filling to perfection.
Sold from May until the end of August.
Coconut Cream Pie - Pick Up
Coconut Cream Pie - Pick Up
Our Price: $15.00

Fresh coconut is added to this handmade custard for a rich creamy taste.  Toasted coconut is added to the whip cream topping so it's bursting with flavor.
Lemon Meringue Pie - Pick Up
Lemon Meringue Pie - Pick Up
Our Price: $15.00

The tart lemon filling topped with a baked meringue is sure to be a hit.
Banana Cream Pie - Pick Up
Banana Cream Pie - Pick Up
Our Price: $15.00

For pick up only.  Fresh bananas are turned into this handmade custard.
Cherry Crumb Pie - Pick Up
Cherry Crumb Pie - Pick Up
Our Price: $15.00

Tart sour cherries with a sweet crumb topping make this a sensational pie.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie - Pick Up
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie - Pick Up
Our Price: $15.00

For pick up only. A chocolate ganache coated graham pie crust loaded with a peanut butter filling. We then drizzle more chocolate ganache on top and add in 7 peanut butter cups. Rich and tasty. This pie needs to be kept frozen until use.
Our #1 selling pie.