Home > Cookies > Old Fashioned Cookies > In Store Pick Up Only - Please specify Pick Up DATE in "ORDER COMMENTS" Box upon checkout
Sort By:
Page of 3
Chocolate Chip - Pick up
Our Price: $6.25

This all American cookie is great for any occasion.
Oatmeal Scotchie Cookies - Pick Up
Our Price: $6.25

A wonderful oatmeal cookie full of butterscotch chips. They come in a box of 1 dozen and are approximately 2 1/2 inches in diameter.
Snickerdoodle Cookies - Pick Up
Our Price: $6.25

Our Snickerdoodle cookies are a favorite amongst snickerdoodle lovers. Fun to say with a taste that cannot be matched!These Snickerdoodle cookies come in a box of 1 dozen and are approximately 2 1/2 inches in diameter.
Oatmeal Raisin Cookies - Pick Up
Our Price: $6.50

A wonderful oatmeal cookie full of raisins. They come in a box of 1 dozen and are approximately 2 1/2 inches in diameter.
Snowball Cookies - Pick Up
Our Price: $6.50

Our snowball cookies have just the right amount of nut taste using fresh ground walnuts and powdered sugar coating. They are approximately 1 1/4 inch in diameter and come in a box of 1 dozen.

Note: To keep your snowballs powdery white, roll them again in powdered sugar before serving.
Peanut Butter Cookies - Pick Up
Our Price: $6.50

A cookie for the peanut butter lover! Remember the commercial "Choosy mothers choose JIF"?  We believe choosy bakeries choose JIF too.  Our delicious peanut butter cookies are just like mom used to bake and in some cases maybe even better.  They come in a box of 1 dozen and are approximately 2 1/2 inches in diameter.
Chocolate Candy Cookies - Pick Up
Our Price: $6.50

A colorful classic. Our chocolate candy cookies will surely brighten your day! No fake chocolate candies here. We use real M & M's in the dough.
These cookies come in a box of 1 dozen and measure approximately 2 1/2 inches in diameter. They are packaged for pick up.
Please specify pick up date in the message box upon check out.
Chocolate Candy Cookies Red/Green - Pick Up
Our Price: $6.50

A colorful classic. Our chocolate candy cookies will surely brighten your day! No fake chocolate candies here. We use real M & M's in the dough.
These cookies come in a box of 1 dozen and measure approximately 2 1/2 inches in diameter. They are packaged for pick up.
Please specify pick up date in the message box upon check out.
Thumbprint Cookie Shells - pu
Our Price: $6.50

Our thumbprint cookies add nice color to any assortment of cookies. Ground walnuts and brown sugar make up this dough. We sell the thumbprint shell for all those who may want to put their favorite jelly in them.
Sold by the dozen.
Thumbprint Cookies Red/Green - Pick up
Our Price: $6.75

Ground walnuts are added to the brown sugar dough and we fill them with our popular cookie frosting.
They are packaged by the dozen.